Pages

Tuesday 20 May 2014

Divergent by Veronica Roth

Okay, I admit it-I'm a bad book blogger. I went to see Divergent before reading the book...and I'm very glad I did. The movie Divergent is a refreshing take on the YA genre with a female protagonist who isn't afraid to kick butt and a romance that takes a backseat to the far more pressing matters of mass extermination and the threat of war. Sadly, the same cannot be said for the book Divergent.

 Tris is a girl who has grown up living in a world where everyone gets neatly sorted into groups based on their key personality traits. Unlike everyone else though, Tris is divergent which means that the test which does the sorting doesn't work on her. Instead she gets to choose her faction and spend the rest of the series wondering if she made the right choice.

It may sound like your standard YA dystopian stuff and for the most part, I guess it is. While movie Tris was pretty badass and had better things to focus on than her lovelife, book Tris sadly does not. Instead we get page upon page of her fretting about Tobi-I mean Four, the cookie cutter brooding bad boy of this series.
Don't get me wrong, Divergent is not a bad book. It still has a fairly engaging plot (which admittedly drags a bit) and the heroine does have to make some tough choices which are a lot darker than those found in say, Twilight. It's just a disappointment after seeing a movie which was a breath of fresh air to then go and find out that the book is more of the same. I would definitely recommend the movie but if you want to know whether you should check out the book, really I'd say it's up to you. There is nothing particularly special here but if you like dystopias then I see no reason why this one is any worse than any of the other hundreds upon the shelf. At least it spares us the grief of a love triangl-

Oh wait. There's a sequel. What are the odds we'll escape it the second time?


Overall Score:
 

Saturday 3 May 2014

The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams

Oh, I was so excited to read this book.

I'd heard great things about it. It's so rare to find a genuinely funny book and all my friends had raved about it, I was so sure I would love it. It sounded exactly like my cup of tea with a humorous narrative style and playfully absurd characters. And to be fair, it is both of those things. It did make me laugh at times, it made me smile a lot and I can't say I didn't enjoy reading it.

I just wish it had more substance.

I can hear the cries of anger now. 'But that's not the point! It's meant to be a funny book, you're not supposed to take it seriously!'. And okay, I get that. But I'm sorry, a book, a movie, anything should still have something to say. You should still finish it feeling like you've gained something simply from experiencing it. Can I honestly say I gained anything from Hitchhiker's?
Let me make this clear, I don't hate this book by any means. It was enjoyable, it was fun and it killed some time. But about three-quarters of the way through I realised it wasn't going to turn out to be the clever thing I'd been hoping for and that, coupled with a lack of a proper ending, meant I just couldn't love it. I'm sorry sci-fi fans. I know I should know better. But this book simply wasn't for me.

Overall Score:
.5